Last week’s loadshedding was another reminder of how fragile the Medupi power station is. With Kusile, these power stations were supposed to be the flagships of South Africa’s power generation but instead of that; it has become as Bloomberg put it “textbook studies on how not to execute large infrastructure projects.” There seems to be a realisation in government circles that these two power stations cannot be trusted to provide for the country’s future electricity needs as the government prepared itself to move away from coal power stations to renewable energy in its energy road map for the country that has recently been published. Medupi’s power station manager Rudi van der Wal also appears to have given it up as a lost case and has left Eskom to “take up a position overseas.” Eskom confirmed that Van der Wal’s resignation was not linked to the latest blackouts. Energy expert Chris Yelland unpacks what went wrong in the latest loadshedding schedule imposed on electricity users and concludes that it is “the stuff of nightmares.” – Linda van Tilburg
Medupi magic fails Eskom and South Africa – the stuff of nightmares
By Chris Yelland*
Following major problems that brought Eskom’s Medupi power station to its knees during the height of the load shedding last week, Medupi’s power station manager, Rudi van der Wal, is leaving Eskom to take up a position overseas.
Van der Wal had resigned before the mess started, and was due to leave in about two weeks. But after the mess started, he was made to step aside, and was replaced before his pending departure.
Other staff at Medupi have been dismissed by Eskom’s head of generation, Bheki Nxumalo, for negligence, in what Eskom COO Jan Oberholzer calls “consequence management” following a number of major problems at Medupi that contributed to the load shedding last week.
Additional problems at Medupi power station have now been identified that have not been previously disclosed to the public by Eskom’s management, while Medupi and Kusile are emerging as major threats to the adequacy of the power system to meet demand in South Africa.
For some time, the stackers that load coal from Exxaro’s Grootegeluk mine onto the stockpiles at the Medupi stockyard, and the reclaimers that take coal from the stockpiles to feed coal by conveyor to the power station boilers, have not been working.
So, to get fuel to the Medupi boilers, the coal stockyard was bypassed, and the single main coal conveyor feed from Grootegeluk mine was feeding the power station directly, without any redundancy in the system. So, effectively, Medupi was running with minimal coal stock at its disposal.
Thus, when the 4,5 km single main coal conveyor feed from the Grootegeluk mine failed on the Eskom side with a broken belt, Medupi was left with no coal feeding its boilers other than about one or two shifts worth of fuel in the bunkers at each boiler.
To add to the disaster, it is now clear that blocked chute and belt rip detectors on the conveyor were not working. Thus, the conveyor did not trip when it should have done so in order to protect the system. This caused damage to some 700 m of belt, as well as damage to the conveyor structures.
With the main coal conveyor from Grootegeluk mine down, and the stacker/reclaimers at the Medupi stockyard not working, coal now had to be transported by truck from the stockyard, for offloading at the emergency Buffalo conveyors at the boiler bunkers, in order to get fuel to the boilers. This was a major logistical nightmare due to the huge volumes of coal involved. Major congestion of coal trucks transporting coal from the stockyard to the bunkers forced the power output of Medupi to be reduced to a third of normal, thus contributing to load shedding
Then problems were experienced with the ash-handling plant, which conveys ash from coal that is burned in the boilers to the ash dumps. Staff working on the bunker feed problems were shifted to deal with the huge build-up of ash, thus compounding the problems.
The good news is that the main coal conveyor from Grootegeluk mine is expected to be operating again shortly, thus relieving the logistical problem of transporting coal by truck and manually offloading the coal at the emergency Buffalo conveyors to feed to the boiler bunkers.
The bad news is that the stacker/reclaimers are still not working. So, with the coal stockyard bypassed, Medupi remains vulnerable and dependent on a single, long, conveyor feed from Grootegeluk mine, without any redundancy if the conveyor should fail or trip for whatever reason.
Summary of issues at Medupi
In summary, the known problems at Eskom’s Medupi power station include:
- The main conveyor from Grootegeluk mine feeding coal to Medupi failed, causing belt and structural damage.
- Protection devices on the conveyor failed to detect the fault timeously.
- The stacker/reclaimers at the Medupi coal stockyard are not working, and the coal stockyard is thus bypassed.
- Coal was being transported by truck from the stockyard to the boiler bunkers, causing massive congestion and forcing reduced power output of the generators.
- The coal mills are of wrong design, causing excessive wear and tear, with increased maintenance and downtime.
- The design height of the boilers is inadequate (i.e. too low), thus causing excessive temperatures within the boiler and flue gas.
- Excessive flue gas temperature is causing premature failure of the pulse-jet fabric filters, which are essential for fly ash collection and pollution control.
- The ash handling system is unable to cope with the volume of bottom ash and fly ash from the boilers.
- Chris Yelland, investigative editor, EE Publishers.